Danish Dari German Spanish French Turkish Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
News stories world-wide
News 2011
News 2010
News 2009
News 2008
News 2007
News 2006
News 2005
News 2004
News 2003
News 2002
News 2001
About music censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Activities
Links
Press room

NEWS
28 April 2006

Sweden:
Religious group attempts to silence music

On 25 April 2006, a documentary programme on SVT, the National Swedish TV, showed how a group of young, religious men in Sweden act as if they were an Islamic police force and try to prevent Swedish Muslims – basically of Somali origin – from listening to music

By Freemuse

"Music is not allowed in Islam", says Faik Rustemi, 23, in an interview with SVT-reporter Magnus Wennerholm. Faik Rustemi is a member of the youth organisation, TUFF, based in Malmö, Sweden’s third largest city.

In a one hour TV documentary entitled ‘Reportage: Så motarbetas integrationen’ (“Report: In this way integration is obstructed”) Magnus Wennerholm spoke to a number of Muslims in Sweden, fundamentalists as well as moderates, about Islam and integration. A particular focus was put on ‘Salafis’, who are devoted to a very strict interpretation of Islam and have very tight connections to the Wahabi interpretation of Islam that dominates Saudi Arabia.

The TV crew filmed how a group of young Salafi men – all with long beards, Arabic jallabiya shirts and trousers which do not cover the ankles – blocked the roads around a concert hall in a suburb of Gothenburg, Sweden’s second largest city.

With threatening remarks, the Salafi believers attempted to prevent people attending a party organised by young people of Somali background. It wasn't until Swedish police arrived and ordered the men to leave the place, did the young people dare to enter the concert hall.

Produced by SVT’s most prestigious documentary team 'Uppdrag granskning', a tv-reviewer at the Swedish daily, Expressen, wrote that the documentary was "the most important TV programme of the year".


The SVT documentary shows the Salafi group obstructing a Swedish-Somali music event



Munajjid: Music is forbidden

In Arabic the word “Salaf” means “predecessors” (or ancestors) and refers to the Companions of the Prophet Muhammad, the early Muslims who followed them, and the scholars of the first three generations of Muslims. They are also called Al-Salaf Al-Salih or "the Righteous Predecessors".

The religious ban on music is promoted by Muslim scholars in Saudi Arabia such as Shaykh Munajjid who runs an “Islam Question & Answer” website which declares that music – even ring tones on mobile phones – are totally forbidden according to Islam. ("It is not permissible to use musical tunes for telephones or any other devices, because listening to musical instruments is haram, as is indicated by the evidence of sharee’ah.") In the documentary, Magnus Wennerholm shows Faik Rustemi as a close follower of Shaykh Munajjid, and has translated and used many of Munajjid’s statements.

A quote from another (presently defunct) Swedish website, Muslimer.com, is included in the documentary: “Some people gather on Eid with the purpose of singing and other sorts of unnecessary entertainment, and this is not allowed”.


Shut the radio off

The SVT team visits the school Al-Salam Skolan in Örebro which receives funds from Saudi Arabia. They interview the former head master, Elisabeth Söderling, who says that she thought it was insane that listening to radio was banned - she wasn’t even allowed to listen to a news channel because of its jingles.

Reporter Magnus Wennerholm, researcher Per Brinkemo and editor Kenny Adersjö have been working on the documentary since October 2005. After the programme had been broadcast on Swedish television they were chatting and debating with viewers who showed an unusually high interest, sending in around 1,700 questions and comments.

The subject is discussed on numerous webpages and debate forums. On the website Sindbad.se which is one of the largest of its kind in Sweden, a school pupil takes on the advice that he should “play hookie” from the music lessons in school. A few quotes from the website:

        Written by ibn Shahzad on Saturday Oct 16, 2004 21:31
        Salamuelykom brothers and sisters!
        It is not allowed to listen to music. Does this mean you are breaking the rules when you participate in the subject in school? If I don’t attend, I will get lower marks, and I want high marks. What should I do? Should I go to the music lessons or…?
        Your little brother Sayed

        Written by Gäst on Sunday Oct 17, 2004 15:00
        Asalaamu3alikum!
        My advice to you is that make an end to attending the music classes (even though that I would have wished I myself had listened to my own advice here, I attended around 10 percent of the music lessons but Alhamdulillah I managed to get even a G in the subject) …
        I understand that you want the best marks, but what is better, to be prosperous in this live, or in the next one and obtaining the mercy of Allah. (…)
        So inshaAllah and may Allah strengthen your imaan amiin

In beginning of 2006, the Swedish newspaper Sydsvenskan published a special theme report on “prohibitions in Islam”. Among other articles, they published an interview with two young Muslim teenagers based in Malmö who say that there is an increased pressure on Muslim women to refrain from dancing and playing music, because it is forbidden.















Magnus Wennerholm
Photo: SVT










































Shaykh Munajjid
Photo: Saudi TV














Click to read more
Contrary viewpoint
"There is no ban on music in the Koran, and those talking about which music is forbidden have very weak evidence" said Shaykh Ibrahim Ramadan Al-Mardini at a Freemuse conference in Beirut. Click on photo to read more.
Photo: Marie Korpe

Sources:

SVT, 'Uppdrag Granskning' – 25 April 2006 (in Swedish):
'Så motarbetas integrationen i Sverige'

Watch the tv programme (in Swedish):

svt.se/mediacenter

Shaykh Munajjid's official website:

www.islam-qa.com

The free encyclopedia Wikipedia:

About “Salafi”



Expressen – 26 April 2006 (in Swedish):
’Britta Svensson: Jag håller på Vitryssland i Schlager-EM’

Official home page for Al-Salam Skolan (in Swedish):

www.alsalam.se

Sindbad.se – October 2004 (Swedish debate forum, in Swedish):

Discussion about music lessons in school

Sydsvenskan – 10 February 2006:

‘Flickor hotas av muslimska åsiktspoliser’

BBC News – 24 November 2005:

BBC Radio 4 visits a privately-run Muslim school in Lancashire  – where music is seen as un-Islamic


Similar incidents have been reported in Copenhagen, Denmark, in 2004:
Religious fundamentalists obstruct Copenhagen concert

Go to top
Related reading

Three films about music and Islam hit Scandinavia
Pakistani rock star Salman Ahmad and editor Simon Broughton visit Denmark and Sweden in February 2007 to show three documentary films about music and Islam
24 January 2007
Sweden: Religious group attempts to silence music
A group of young, religious men in Sweden act like as if they were an Islamic police force and try to prevent Swedish muslims from listening to music
28 April 2006
Austin Dacey, USA: Expanding the boundaries
A presentation by Austin Dacey, followed by a debate which took place at the conference 'Right! Freedom of Music & Speech' on 21 November 2011 in Stockholm
25 November 2011
Sweden: The conference 'Right! Freedom of Music & Speech'
Questions about censorship and repression are investigated at the international conference ‘Right! Freedom of Music & Speech’ held at Södra Teatern in Stockholm, Sweden
02 November 2011
Sweden: Death threats to DJ for Facebook debate about gender issues
A seemingly uncontroversial post on the Facebook profile of the night club Slakthuset resulted in death threats against 21-year-old DJ Tova Wellton
08 August 2011
The Nordic countries: Academic network for reseaching music censorship
Over 40 professors, university researchers and students from the Nordic countries have established a network to provide an informed knowledge about music censorship
04 July 2011
Sweden: Hip-hop performances cancelled because of controversial lyrics
The hip-hop group Labyrint from Uppsala was stopped from performing in Växjö and Värnamo after a notice from police authorities saying their lyrics glorify drugs
09 May 2011
Sweden: What do Swedish music associations do for freedom of speech?
Composer and acting chairman of the European Composer and Songwriter Alliance, Alfons Karabuda, writes in his blog about artistic creators and freedom of expression
01 December 2010
Sweden: Music associations should engage in freedom of speech
Representatives of musicians' associations in Sweden say to national radio: “It is about time that we begin to engage in free speech issues along the lines of Freemuse.”
17 November 2010
Sweden: Safe cities for musicians
"All over Europe city councils are hosting persecuted writers. Why not persecuted musicians?", asked Kerstin Brunnberg, chairperson of the Swedish Arts Council
17 November 2010