Freemuse: Denmark: Calling to cancel Jamaican reggae star concert

News stories world-wide

About music censorship

NEWS

26 July 2006

Denmark:
Calling to cancel Jamaican reggae star concert

The Jamaican Reggae singer Buju Banton was met with demonstrations and callings to cancel his concert when he played at The Rock in Copenhagen on July 11, 2006

Representatives of the gay and lesbian community in Denmark demanded the concert cancelled and arranged demonstrations against Buju Banton who is known for his lyrics against homosexuality.

Representatives of the concert hall The Rock met with representatives of the gay and lesbian community before the concert. The organisers refused to cancel the event. However they said that Buju Banton was informed that if he played some of his controversial songs, the concert would be stopped.

Buju Banton’s concert at The Rock was part of an international tour which also included a stop-over in Brighton, UK. According to an article in the Danish newspaper Fyens Stiftstidende the Brighton concert was cancelled due to interference from the local police and politicians. In 2004, Brighton was the first UK city to demand that music retailers ban reggae and rap albums with "anti-gay" lyrics.

Buju Banton – some of his lyrics are overtly against homosexuality

Not everything is allowed

As a point of departure, no censorship can be imposed or subsequent legal steps be taken against musicians because of what they express in their music. The European Court of Human Rights has interpreted artistic freedom of expression in a broad way. In a judgement from 1988 the Court observed, that "Those who create, perform, distribute or exhibit works of art contribute to the exchange of ideas and opinions which is essential for a democratic society. Hence the obligation on the State not to encroach unduly on their freedom of expression".

However, there are exceptions, e.g.:
• Propaganda for war is always unlawful, as is advocacy for national, racial or religious hatred.
• States may also limit freedom of expression if it is necessary for a certain number of other reasons:
• Respect of the reputations of others (defamation),
• Protection of national security, public order, or of public health or morals.

In any case such limitations must be prescribed in a national law.

Sources (in Danish): Fyens Stifttidende - 8 July 2006: Demonstration mod homofobisk reggaekoncert TV2 Lorry - 6 July 2006: Kontroversiel koncert vækker harme i homomiljøet

Related reading

Reggae stars 'help to spread HIV'

International Development Minister Gareth Thomas fears that discrimination against homosexuals is deterring people from being tested for HIV. "A number of artistes are effectively contributing to the spread of HIV by producing reggae and rap songs actually encouraging discrimination"

22 November 2004

'Anti-gay' lyrics inquiry starts

The government is considering banning reggae star Sizzla from the UK. Meanwhile detectives are investigating claims that lyrics penned by eight leading reggae artists incite violence against homosexuals and are therefore illegal.

03 November 2004

South Africa: Old anti-apartheid song banned on hate speech charges

On 26 March 2010, a South African high court prohibited the singing of a controversial anti-apartheid song, ‘Ayesab'amagwala’ (‘The cowards are afraid’)

19 April 2010

Middle East: Hip-Hop on the frontline

The rap form allows a powerful voice for political invective, and is being used on both sides of the Israel-Palestine conflict. But for Arab countries and the Middle East, the influence and performance of hip-hop lights a few fuses

02 November 2004

Pop lyrics and their censors

"Political correctness has imposed a new restraint on free speech." Interview with Freemuse co-chair Martin Cloonan on explicit lyrics and music censorship today

15 January 2004

Denmark: Activist campaigns against online sales of 'murder music'

Online music stores that sell so-called 'murder music' (reggae with lyrics inciting to violence against homosexuals) receive complaints from Danish gay rights activist

22 May 2008

New Zealand: Controversial American hip-hop group's concert cancelled

The Big Day Out festival removed the American rap group Odd Future from the festival's Auckland lineup due to objections from locals over the group's homophobic lyrics

15 November 2011

United Kingdom: Ban on abusive chants by football fans

The British football club Tottenham Hotspur has vowed to ban fans guilty of offensive or abusive chanting. The Scottish government is considering a law about it

05 October 2011

South Africa: Anti-apartheid song declared 'hate speech'

On 12 September 2011, South Africa’s high court banned the ruling ANC party from singing the old anti-apartheid song ‘Shoot the Boer’

13 September 2011

UK / Scotland: Offensive football songs criminalised

Scottish football fans could be imprisoned for up to six years for singing offensive songs if an ‘Offensive Behaviour at Football Bill’ is passed in the Scottish Parliament

01 August 2011