Danish Dari German Spanish French Turkish Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
News stories world-wide
News 2009
News 2008
News 2007
News 2006
News 2005
News 2004
News 2003
News 2002
News 2001
About music censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Activities
Links
Press room

NEWS
15 August 2007

USA:
Rock group’s anti-Bush statement allegedly censored

After Pearl Jam's live show on 5 August 2007, the band was informed by fans that parts of the webcast of their concert had been left out by the main sponsor AT&T. There was an interruption of the webcast when the lead singer made a statement against the American president Bush.

By Kristina Funkeson, Freemuse

Webcast watchers could hear lead singer Eddie Vedder sing “George Bush, leave this world alone” and then the webcast was abruptly interrupted, followed by a long silence. The lyrics left out in the webcast contained Vedder repeating the phrase again, and then singing “George Bush find yourself another home”.

The anti-Bush segment was sung to the melody of Pink Floyd's ‘Another Brick in the Wall’ during the performance of Pearl Jam's song ‘Daughter’.

The members of Pearl Jam commented what happened on their homepage: “This, of course, troubles us as artists but also as citizens concerned with the issues of censorship and the increasingly consolidated control of the media.”

Error?
According to MTV News, AT&T claimed that the incident was not a censorship issue but merely an “unintended error” made by one of the webcast vendors subcontracted by the AT&T. However, it was not further explained why the editing happened during the anti-Bush statements though nothing else was cut out of the broadcast.

At first, AT&T claimed that the ‘mistake’ during the Pearl Jam webcast was a solitary incident. But after fans quickly reported about other incidents earlier this summer, AT&T released a statement admitting that similar ‘mistakes’ has indeed happened in the past in a “handful of cases”. In the statement, cited by MTV News, AT&T also says that it’s not their intent to “edit political comments in webcasts”.

Political censorship
According to information provided by fans, cited by MTV News, the other sets affected by AT&T’s ‘unintended censorship’ were concerts by Flaming Lips and John Butler Trio as well as Nightwatchman, also known as Tom Morello from Rage Against the Machine. It seems like the parts left out of these concerts, as well as the Pearl Jam set, was characterised by a political theme.

Freedom of speech
Judging from all the publicity in newspapers as well as web forums and blogs on the Internet, Americans are very upset by the incidents that clearly threaten their First Amendment – the freedom of speech.

“What happened this weekend was a wake up call, and it’s about something much bigger than the censorship of a rock band”, Pearl Jam stated on their website. The band underlined their worries about corporations having the power to determine what people hear and see in the media.

Ironically – thanks to the attention attracted by the AT&T editing – Pearl Jam’s statement could hardly have reached more people. The signature ‘tubegem74’ commented on Youtube: “Rather than having Ed's msg heard only by those of us there, the whole world gets to hear it :)”






Photo courtesy of Kerensa Wight
Eddie Vedder suggested that the American president should leave the world alone.




Click here to read the report
Read more about Pearl Jam in the Freemuse report about the freedom of expression in the US post 9/11.

Video

See both versions – the censored and the un-censored part of the concert – on youtube.com:
‘Pearl Jam Daughter (Lollapalooza 2007)See For Yourself...’


Sources

Pearl Jam’s official homepage:
pearljam.com

MTV News – 9 August 2007:
‘Pearl Jam Wonder: Were Anti-Bush Comments Edited From Webcast Really An 'Error'?’

MTV News – 13 August 2007:
‘AT&T Admits It Edited Webcasts Before Pearl Jam's’



Go to top
Latest news on freemuse.org

Mahsa Vahdat
Two video interviews with Iranian singer Mahsat Vahdat. About women, religion, and music censorship in modern Iran
02 September 2010
Guatemala: Teacher of indigenous music brutally murdered
Leonardo Lisandro Guarcax, promoter and defender of indigenous maya culture, has been found dead after he was abducted by unknown assailants on 25 August 2010
31 August 2010
Cameroon: Lapiro fires back at Minister of Communication
Lapiro de Mbanga, imprisoned since 2008 retaliates at Minister of Communication who on 30 July 2010 announced that Cameroon did not host any political prisoners
30 August 2010
Russia: Concert banned but protest singer continue unplugged
On 22 August 2010, Yuri Shevchuk, a popular rock singer and political critic, defied the Russian authorities' sudden ban on a staged protest concert and performed without amplification
27 August 2010
Azagaia
Video interview with Azagaia - a Mozambican hip-hop artist, rapper and sociologist - about freedom of expression and self-censorship among musicians in his country
25 August 2010
Myanmar/Burma: Freemuse in joint campaign for imprisoned comedian
The Free Zarganar Campaign, which advocates for the release of Burmese comedian Zarganar, urges MEP's to nominate him for the European Parliament's Sakharov Price
25 August 2010
Venezuela: Reggae artist defies government ban on violent images
Venezuelan authorities are set to launch an investigation into a music video called 'Rotten Town' by reggae artist Onechot that depicts the current state of violence in the country
24 August 2010
Somalia: Al-Shabaab bans music like the Taliban
Somalia is starting to resemble Afghanistan under the Taliban, where hard-line Islamist militia bans music and movies and forbids the public from watching sports on TV
23 August 2010
Saudi Arabia: King limits clerics who can issue fatwas
A decree sent by King Abdullahs office states that only senior Islamic clerics appointed by him can issue fatwas and religious rulings
19 August 2010
Zimbabwe: Opposition music denied airtime
As Zimbabweans brace for a possible election next year, contesting political parties have turned to music for their campaigns
18 August 2010
Newsletter no. 3 / 2010
Freemuse Newsletter no. 2 / 2010
12 August 2010
Funding
Who is funding Freemuse?
12 August 2010
Freemuse receives grant from The Sigrid Rausing Trust
The Sigrid Rausing Trust has awarded a grant of £50,000 for the next year to the work of Freemuse
12 August 2010
Smashed Hits 2.0
On 8 September 2010, the British magazine Index on Censorship publishes a special theme issue on music censorship entitled ‘Smashed hits 2.0’
12 August 2010
United Arab Emirates: Censored rap duo ready with new album
The first and only album of the Emirati hip-hop duo Desert Heat which came out in 2008, was banned in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait, reported AFP
12 August 2010
EU policy library refers to Freemuse Visa White Paper
The Freemuse report ‘Visas / The Discordant Note’ has been included as an official research document in the EU Commission's 'Library of Policy Documents'
11 August 2010
Songlines review of Freemuse CD: ‘It is Top of the World’
Songlines, an influential UK-based world music magazine, has chosen the CD ‘Listen to the banned’ as ‘Top of the World’ in their August 2010 issue
11 August 2010
search_test
09 August 2010
Iran: Supreme leader discourages music
Music is ‘not compatible’ with the values of the Islamic Republic, announced Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on 2 August 2010
04 August 2010
Turkey: Date of next hearing set in Ferhat Tunç's case
The date for the next hearing in the case against musician and Freemuse Award winner Ferhat Tunç has been set to 30 September 2010
04 August 2010