Danish Dari German Spanish French Turkish Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
News stories world-wide
News 2009
News 2008
News 2007
News 2006
News 2005
News 2004
News 2003
News 2002
News 2001
About music censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Activities
Links
Press room

NEWS
08 September 2008

Turkey:
Jail sentence to Kurdish folk singer

Folk music singer Hasan Sağlam was sentenced to 10 months' imprisonment for “making terrorist propaganda” because he sang the Kurdish song ‘Vuruldu Sevdamız Kirvem’ at the Munzur Festival in Tunceli in 2007.

The song’s title, ‘Vuruldu Sevdamız Kirvem’, means: ‘Our love was shot, my kirve’ — where kirve is a name used among Kurdish people for someone who helps a boy during circumcision and usually has a very close relation to this boy, almost like brotherhood.

Hasan Sağlam sang this song at the Munzur Festival in Tunceli on 12 August 2007. The lyrics in the song is a mourning over 17 Kurdish militants who were killed in an army air raid.

Unable to appeal
An indictment against the singer was prepared on 22 February 2008, and in August 2008 the Malatya Third High Criminal Court convicted Hasan Sağlam as guilty. The sentence has not been executed, though, because of a court procedure where the Malatya court deliberately postponed the declaration of the decision. This prevents Hasan Sağlam from being able to appeal the decision, and the conviction from being executed.

At the court hearing Hasan Sağlam noted that he was a folk singer and that “the only way for me to express myself is through folk songs.” He also told the Danish newspaper Politiken: “A year in prison won’t make any big difference, but I see this court case as a strategy for creating fear among artists, a kind of blackmailing for making them keep quiet. By nature I am against the killing of human beings, and I only did my duty as an artist to tell them this.”

    Translation of the song
    'Vuruldu Sevdamız Kirvem'


    Our love was shot, my kirve

    Our love was shot, my kirve
    Answer my voice, Mercan Mountains
    Could not you hide my kirve?
    I'd prefer that death took me and I died
    Don't you have any respect to the visitor, Mercan Mountains?
    Mountains of death, Erzincan mountains

    Set me free, let me climb up to Munzur
    Let me tell my trouble to dear Haydar

    It's not only one wound, but 17 that I have
    Our love was shot, my kirve, at the mountain of death

    Do not the birds build nests on your hills?
    What is your spring or summer good for?
    Could not you send a message to my soul comrade?
    You were arm in arm with the hunter, Mercan Mountains

    Mountains of death, Erzincan mountains
    It is not worthwhile,
    I will not slander you, Mercan Mountains
    Let the mothers mourn,
    Ah, my kirve

    It's not only one wound, but 17 that I have
    Our love was shot
    Our love was shot at Mercan Mountains
    at the mountains of death

The 17 wounds mentioned in the song belong to 17 members of the Maoist Communist Party – People's Liberation Army (MKP–HKO), including some of their leaders, who were killed in an operation at Tunceli. The song was composed in their memory.

About the postponing of the declaration
Postponing the declaration of a sentence means that the decision will not bring any legal consequence for the sentenced. It is legally possible that the court may give such a decision in cases that the sentence is lower than one year (or equivalent fine), that is if the accused had not committed a similar crime before and the court believes that he/she would not repeat a similar crime in the future recognizing his/her respectful behaviour during the hearings.

In such a case, the sentenced is to be kept under observation for five years. If he/she violates the regulations of control during this period or commits a new and similar crime, then the court declares the postponed decision and it is executed. But in case he/she obeyes the rules, then the case is dropped.

It is possible to object such a decision, but not possible to appeal it at the Court of Cassation (Highest level). The first step is to apply to the same court. If the court does not agree with the objection, it sends the case to another similar court. In this case, the objection may go to another criminal court in that region, but not the Court of Cassation, which is a higher court.






Hasan Sağlam


 
About the artist
Hasan Sağlam was born on 25 October 1972 in Tunceli (the new name for what was previously called Dersim). He began singing as a student in primary school, and also used to sing while looking after sheep. He wrote his first song when he was 13 years old, while starting to play the balgama instrument.

Hasan Sağlam tells:
“I had a childhood which passed by looking at people who were carrying weapons. As we grew up, the load on our shoulders became increasing heavy. News about deaths, smell of gunpowder. First forests were burned, then villages. Our village was burnt in 1994. This was when our journey to exile started. All songs that I have been singing transfers me to my childhood, and the childhood of my father. The execuation of Seyid Rıza. The blood which was bleeding through Lac River, keys of mountains, and exiles.”

Hasan Sağlam started working as a professional musicial in Burs when he and Haydar Mollu founded a ten-person musicial group named Mayıs Türküsü (Song of May) in 1996. While we were running on the musicial life the death of our friend Hasan Mollu was interrupted us.

The group seperated when Hasan Mollu died. Some members of the band moved to European countries, while Hasan Sağlam moved to İstanbul in 2001 where he recorded his first solo album in Kurdish, entitled ‘Vengdais’ (‘Hollering’). In 2003, he wrote and recorded the song ‘Dersim Çığlığı’ (‘Screaming of Dersim’).

In 2005, Hasan Sağlam had his first poetry book published by Ceylan Publish-House, entitled ‘Dersim, Where and How Shall I Hide?’

One of his most recents works is the song ‘Veng u Vaz’ (‘Word and Voice’) published by Iber Music.

About the Munzur Festival
Munzur is the name of a valley in the province of Tunceli. It is considered one of most beautiful valleys in Turkey. The Turkish government plans to build eight dams in the valley to produce electricity. Citizens of Tunceli, however — scientists, actors, actresses, writers, and intellectualls — believe that the Munzur Dams will not support fraternity of Turkey, it will only destroy the nature of the area.

So since 2001 the Tunceli Municipality has been organising the Munzur Festival to protest against the building of the dams, and to create a general awareness in the society about the issue. The festival takes place annually in August, and includes seminar, lectures, panel debates as well as concerts.

About Dersim and its rebellion
On 1 November 1936, during a speech in parliament, Turkeys leader Atatürk said that Dersim was Turkey’s most important internal problem. During the Ottoman period, the authorities had been unable to make the Dersim pay taxes or recognise any authority other than their own. This situation continued in the early years of the Turkish Republic which had been founded by Atatürk. In an Interior Ministry report in 1926, it was stated that it was considered necessary to use force against Dersim.

During 1937 and 1938 there was an uprising in Dersim. It can actually be seen as two different uprisings, separated by a hard winter. The first uprising went from late March 1937 to November 1937, while the second began in April 1938 and lasted until December 1938. Labelled as ‘The Dersim Rebellion’ the two uprisings were led by the local traditional Kizilbash elites, at the head of whom stood Seyit Riza, chief of the Abasusagi tribe. Local intellectual cadres also played a role in the uprising’s leadership, according to one source.

After the revolt which was brutally defeated, authorities changed the name to Tunceli.

Busdriver accused
In another similar case, a Kurdish busdriver has recently been taken to court for playing a Kurdish song in his bus. He was sentenced to 10 months imprisonment, just like Hasan Sağlam, and also in this case has the declaration of the sentence been postponed.






Hasan Sağlam

Sources

Scanning of the indictment about Hasan Sağlam (in Turkish language):

Dosya No 2008 / 50 - Sanik: Hasan Saglam

Article about Hasan Sağlam's case (in Turkish language):

Scanning of newspaper article

Antenna Turkey, Weekly Bulletin – Issue 26/08, 22 August 2008:

antenna-tr.org

Politiken – 3 September 2008 (in Danish language):

'Musik er magt, som stater vil styre'


Go to top
Related reading on freemuse.org

Turkey: Date of next hearing set in Ferhat Tunç's case
The date for the next hearing in the case against musician and Freemuse Award winner Ferhat Tunç has been set to 30 September 2010
04 August 2010
Turkey: Court sentences band to 10 months imprisonment for Kurdish song
The Malatya Criminal Court has sentenced the band members of Grup Munzur to 10 months imprisonment for singing a Kurdish song at a concert held in June 2008
27 July 2010
Turkey: Singer sentenced to 10 months in prison
Singer Cevdet Bağca to serve a 10 months prison term for a statement given to the crowd before his concert in the Turkish town Siirt in September 2009
22 July 2010
Freemuse appeals to Turkish Prime Minister: Dismiss Ferhat Tunç's case
Artists, human rights activists and scholars join Freemuse in an appeal to the Turkish government for the dismissal of the latest court case against Kurdish singer Ferhat Tunç
24 June 2010
Turkey: Kurdish singer Ferhat Tunc faces 15 years in prison
Kurdish singer Ferhat Tunç faces imprisonment of up to 15 years regarding charges of "spreading propaganda for the PKK organisation", the militant Kurdistan Workers' Party
26 May 2010
Turkey: Kurdish music in turmoil of censorship and court cases
A Kurdish song has been banned, and Kurdish singers are being arrested for singing - or just singing along to - specific Kurdish songs, accused of making propaganda
19 May 2010
Lebanon: Song touching 'The Armenian question' banned
Eileen Khatchadourian's music video ‘Zartir Vortyag’ which touches on Armenian topics is reported to have been banned by the Lebanese General Security
03 May 2010
Turkey: German musician detained and told to leave the country
The German DJ Shantel was denied access into Turkey on 14 April 2010 when he arrived at the airport in Istanbul. His concerts had to be canceled.
23 April 2010
Turkey: One year ban and prison sentences to Kurdish music group
Diyarbakır High Criminal Court banned 13 members of Bahar Cultural Centre from performing arts for one year and gave them 10 months prison sentence each
23 April 2010
Turkey: A new investigation against musician Ferhat Tunç
Ferhat Tunç made a formal deposition at a Public Prosecution Office due to an investigation filed against him about a speech he made at a music festival in 2009.
16 April 2010
Freemuse Award 2010: Winners honoured in London
The joint winners of the Freemuse Award 2010, Mahsa Vahdat and Ferhat Tunç, gave a short and impressive performance at the award ceremony in London
29 March 2010
Turkey: Kurdish singer Rojda charged with 20 months imprisonment
In a court in Diyarbakır, the Kurdish singer Rojda Şenses was charged with one year and eight months imprisonment for ‘conducting propaganda’ in two separate concerts
29 March 2010
Freemuse Award winners 2010: Mahsa Vahdat and Ferhat Tunç
Award ceremony held in London on 25 March 2010 in collaboration with Index on Censorship
22 March 2010
Turkey: Killed for singing Kurdish folk songs in bar
A young man, Emrah Gezer, was killed because he and his friends had been singing Kurdish folk songs in a bar
03 March 2010
Turkey: Broadcasting in local languages allowed without time limit
Autorities has granted permission to 14 radio and tv stations in Turkey to broadcast in Kurdish, Zazaki, and Arabic without time limit
03 March 2010
Turkey: Police convicted of beating café worker for playing Kurdish music
Eight months prison sentences were issued by Turkish authorities to two police officers who beat up a 28-year-old café worker for playing an Ahmet Kaya song
03 March 2010
Turkey: Kurdish singer and musician Rojda arrested
Kurdish artist Rojda was arrested for singing a Kurdish song entitled ‘Heval Kamuran’. She was released within a couple of hours
24 February 2010
Turkey: Folk singer and poet on trial for "praising crime"
Tunceli Prosecution Office has filed a case against folk singer Pınar Sağ and poet Mehmet Özcan charging them with two years prison sentences for "praising crime".
17 February 2010
Turkey: Ferhat Tunç sang at large rally for Alevi rights
Ferhat Tunç was one of the artists who performed in Istanbul on 8 November 2009 in front of 200,000 people protesting for the rights of a religious minority
09 November 2009
Turkey: Pop star both condemned and praised for political statement
A statement in favour of a new plan on how the Turkish government should approach the Kurdish issue turned fans of the popular Turkish pop diva Sezen Aksu up against her
14 September 2009