Danish Dari German Spanish French Turkish Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
News stories world-wide
News 2009
News 2008
News 2007
News 2006
News 2005
News 2004
News 2003
News 2002
News 2001
About music censorship
Artists on censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Activities
Links
Press room

NEWS
25 September 2008

Israel:
British musician defied death threats by militants

British musician Paul McCartney defied death threats by religious militants in the Middle East before his concert in Israel where he performed in Tel Aviv for 40,000 fans on 25 September 2008 — 43 years after Israeli authorities banned the Beatles from performing there.

“Paul McCartney survives landmark Israel gig,” headlined the British newspaper The Guardian on its post-concert report. Despite threats for his safety from religious militants, pro-Palestinian groups who asked him not to come, and right-wing Jewish activists who threatened to cause a riot and disrupt the concert to protest against what they perceived as British anti-Semitism, Paul McCartney refused to cancel his concert which celebrated Israel’s 60th anniversary.

He greeted his audience in Park Hayarkon in Tel Aviv with “Shana Tova” to mark the Jewish New Year as well as “Ramadan Karim,” marking the Muslim month of fasting.

Warnings and threats
According to the UK-newspaper Sunday Express, the radical Islamist cleric Omar Bakri Mohammed had warned Paul McCartney that he would earn the enmity of the Muslim world for playing the gig in Tel Aviv. The cleric declared McCartney to be “the enemy of every Muslim” and warned that Paul McCartney’s concert could become “target of suicide bombers” because of the singer’s patronage of Israel.

“If he values his life, Mr McCartney must not come to Israel. He will not be safe there. The sacrifice operatives will be waiting for him,” Omar Bakri told the Sunday Express two weeks before the concert, and an Israeli security analyst was quoted as stating that the threats on McCartney’s life were real.

The 66-year-old rock star was said to be “shocked but not intimidated” by the comments. He told Israeli reporters: “I was approached by different groups and political bodies who asked me not to come here. I refused. I do what I think and I have many friends who support Israel.”

Banned in 1965
McCartney was scheduled to perform in Israel some 43 years ago with the Beatles, the legendary British band of which he was a founding member. But government officials refused to grant the necessary permits, citing concerns that the tousled-haired British band and its strident, amplified music could corrupt the morals of Israeli youth.

Israel made an official apology to the two surviving members of the band this year, when Ron Prosor, the country‘s ambassador to United Kingdom, sent a letter describing the ban as a “misunderstanding”, saying that the tight budget available to music promoters in Israel at the time was as much to blame as fears that Beatlemania could distract the nation's youth.

Ahead of the McCartney concert, newspaper columnist Yossi Sarid, son of the Israeli official who allegedly banned the Beatles in 1965, went on a campaign to clear his father’s name. Yossi Sarid claimed his father had nothing to do with the decision, and that it involved a more mundane feud between two Israeli concert promoters.

Bring people together
Asked by the Guardian if he was concerned that his visit would become politicised, Paul McCartney said: “Music is a great international voice for getting people together. I will do my best to speak to Palestinians and Israelis and get an idea of what the solution might be and support that. But my little bit is to bring people together through music. ”

Varying reports on security
The Paul McCartney show in Israel was said to have costed upward of eight million US dollars to produce, requiring a 100-person production team, and an extensive security of 5,000 officers and guards.

One security source was quoted by the UK’s Daily Mirror as saying: “No one is taking anything for granted. The level of security is unlike anything we’ve seen. Everything is being done to ensure that this passes peacefully and without incident.”

The security army included 20 agents from Israel’s elite Mossad intelligence organisation, officers from Britain’s MI6 and Israeli police officers, at a cost of about 2.8 million US dollars, according to the Mirror.

But the Associated Press reported that only hundreds of police and private security guards were deployed at the concert, quoting police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld as saying that there were no concrete threats against the singer, and no extraordinary security precautions had been taken.







Sources

Weekly Telegraph – 24 September 2008:

'Paul McCartney threatened over Israel concert'

Google News – continously updated:

Search: 'Paul McCartney' + 'threatened'

Sunday Express – 14 September 2008:

'Sir Paul: Terror Target'


Go to top
Related reading on freemuse.org

UK / Israel: Cancellation of show causes censorship row
A London-performance of a group of 19-year-old Israeli soldiers turned singers was cancelled because the owners of the theatre hall claimed it was 'political'
04 May 2009
Palestine: Palestinian youth orchestra disbanded
Palestinian authorities has disbanded a youth orchestra and barred its Arab conductor, Wafa Younes, from a West Bank refugee camp
15 April 2009
Israel: British musician defied death threats by militants
Paul McCartney defied death threats by religious militants in the Middle East before his concert in Israel where he performed for 40,000 fans on 25 September 2008
25 September 2008
Israel: Conference about 'music on troubled soils'
Musicians, politicians and experts gather in Jerusalem, Israel, on 23-26 October 2008 to discuss the role of music in troubled regions such as Israel, Cyprus and South Africa.
22 September 2008
Israel / Palestine: Orchestra prevented from entering Gaza
An international orchestra was refused to perform in Gaza after its sole Palestinian member was prevented from entering the Gaza Strip
17 December 2007
Israel: Censorship controversy over Israeli Eurovision song
A Finnish official tried to ban the Israelis' song from the Eurovision song competition because of its "offending lyrics". The song, however, was approved.
27 March 2007
Kamilya Jubran
Video interview with the Palestinian artist Kamilya Jubran who lives in Israel. She talks about music making and distribution in the shadow of regional conflict
30 October 2006
Israel: Police confiscates CDs with “inflammatory song”
The song ‘Hawk of Lebanon’ by the Palestinian Northern Band has been banned by Israeli authorities. Tapes and CDs containing the song are being confiscated
05 September 2006
Israel: American piano tuner arrested
Paul Larudee, an American who came to tune pianos in Ramallah and Jenin, refused to board a plane against his will and is now waiting for a court decision regarding him
15 June 2006
UK/Israel: Rock star changed his mind about concert venue
Pink Floyd bass player Roger Waters Roger Waters has called off his summer concert in Tel Aviv and will instead perform in a chickpea field near a joint Jewish-Arab village
20 April 2006
UK/Israel: Pink Floyd star rejects cultural boycott
Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters has been asked by Palestinians to cancel his show in Tel Aviv or to put on a separate performance for Palestinians
13 March 2006
Freemuse statement on cultural boycott
The Executive Committee of Freemuse met in Copenhagen on 30 January 2005. One of the issues it discussed was cultural boycotts
07 February 2005
Middle East: Hip-Hop on the frontline
The rap form allows a powerful voice for political invective, and is being used on both sides of the Israel-Palestine conflict. But for Arab countries and the Middle East, the influence and performance of hip-hop lights a few fuses
02 November 2004
Shoot the Singer! Book
"Shoot the Singer! Music Censorship Today". The first worldwide presentation of contemporary cases of music censorship, with cases from i.a. Burma, Mexico, Middle East, France, Algeria, Zimbabwe, USA, South Africa, Turkey. Edited by Freemuse director Marie Korpe, published by Zed Books, May 2004.
25 May 2004
Cultural Boycott - of any use? Freemuse Conference
The recent initiative to boycott Israel is controversial, so is the Arab initiative to boycott cultural events which include Israeli artists. Yet the cultural boycott on apartheid South Africa did have an effect. And what about Cuba? Listen to the panel discussion from WOMEX 2003.
30 November 2003
Rania Elias: Cultural boycott on Israel?
Video Interview with Rania Elias from Palestine - recorded at the WOMEX trade fair in 2002
13 November 2002
Amal Murkus
Video Interview with Amal Murkus. Music and censorship in Israel/Palestine
09 October 2002
Israel: Chava Alberstein banned
Filled with sly humor or sharp criticism of the country’s policies, Alberstein has taken a stand, criticizing Israel’s handling of the Palestinean uprisings. As a result, her music has been banned in the Israeli radio
02 July 2002
Barenboim plays wagner in Jerusalem
Famous conductor causes great turmoil by playing Wagner encore at national festival
09 July 2001
Israel: The Current Wave of the Wagner Debate
The “pro and contra Wagner” debate in Israel is multifaceted and charged with much emotion. Article
20 May 2001