Præsentation af Freemuse på danskPresentacíon de FreemusePrésentation de FreemusePresentation in Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
About music censorship
Artists on censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Articles
Radio programmes
Speeches
Bibliography
Filmography
Freemusepedia
Activities
News
Links
Press room

ARTICLE
25 April 2005

Women and Music Censorship - Past to Present
by Eva Fenn

A summary of the restrictions women have had as singers, as composers and as instrumentalists from the Middle Ages until today, illustrated with individual examples

Download PDF
Read the article as PDF
Read the article as PDF

Eva Fenn is BA-student in "Popular Music and Media", Musikwissenschaftliches Seminar, University of Paderborn, Germany. She was an intern at Freemuse in spring 2005. 

Table of contents
1.       Definitions of censorship
2.       Restrictions on musical women in the Western hemisphere
3.       The situation of female musicians in Iran and Afghanistan
4.       Afghanistan
5.       Women and censorship – Asia – present time
6.       Sources
7.       Bibliography
8.       Timelines
8.1.     Europe / Western Hemisphere
8.2.     Asia
8.3.     Middle East
8.4.     South America
8.5.     Africa
8.6.     Russia

Introduction
Historian and lyric poet Plato from ancient Greece was aware of the power and function music had within society: Music serves to establish the morality and to confirm desirable civic virtues, but simultaneously music also poses a danger that might divert people away from the Good Life. Thus Plato distinguishes in his famous work Res publica between good and bad music and recommended that bad music, as a potential threat of the state, had to be controlled or banned. That’s why dictators throughout time have promoted accommodating composers and music genres and have censured the unaccommodating. But Plato writes nothing of the music of women being worse than music of men. Throughout history many examples can be found illustrating that fact that female music was deemed less valuable.

The article 'Censorship in female music - from past to present' is 28 A4-pages long, and provides examples from all over the world of the censorship of female music over time.
In order to be able to read the PDF document, your computer needs to have the (free) software Acrobat Reader.


Go to top

Excerpts from the Timelines (page 21-28)

Asia
Time: June 2004
Country: China; Chang Hui-Mei (known as A–Mei) – the Taiwanese pop singer canceled a concert in China after a protest accusing her of supporting independence for the island. Reason: China views Taiwan as a renegade province and is suspicious of independence-leaning president Chen Shui-bian.
Source: BBC News, June 13, 2004.
After she had sung at the inauguration of Taiwan’s President Chen Shui-bian in May 2000, she was totally banned from performing and selling records in China. Coca Cola, which had employed her as a poster girl, dropped her under pressure from the government.
Source: Newsweek, January 08, 2001


Chang Hui-Mei

Europe / Western hemisphere
Time: March 2003
Country: USA; Natalie Maines (Dixie Chicks) – many radio stations in the US refused to play their records. Reason: her statement of feeling “ashamed” president Bush came from her home state Texas during a concert in London’s Shepherd’s Bush Empire.
Source: Christiane Rohr, Musiker unter Druck: Zensorische Maβnahmen im Irakkrieg, in: 9/11 – The world’s all out of tune – Populäre Musik nach dem 11. September 2001, Dietrich Helms, Thomas Phleps (Hg.), Bielefeld 2004


Natalie Maines

Middle East
Time: March 2002
Country: Israel; Yafa Yarkoni – the Israeli singer, an Israel Prize winner and an advocate of the consensus, also known as “War Singer” having entertained soldiers in the front for more than half a century, declared that the images she saw of “Defence Shield” reminded her of the Jews and Holocaust. Thus all her concerts were immediately cancelled and she even received threats on her life. Her music almost disappeared from public radio.
Source: Noam Ben-Zeev, The sound of silence: conformist musicians in Israel, in: Marie Korpe (Ed), Shoot the Singer! Music Censorship Today, London, Zed Books, 2004


Yafa Yarkoni

Africa
Time: 1990s
Country Algeria; – Souad Massi – She was threatened and censored for her political stance in her native country, now she makes music from her self-imposed exile in Paris continuing the fight for the rights of women and Berber in Algeria.

Read more
Souad Massi - read more
Souad Massi

Go to top
Read more:

Tanzania - Zanzibar: 'Give sex or be blacklisted'
Why do we see and hear little of women musicians in Zanzibar? Report from an island where parents and husbands are at the core of strong 'cultural censorship'
24 April 2008
Canada: 'Gangsta rap' seeked banned
A Toronto activist has filed a complaint against Canadian music store chain HMV selling 'gangsta rap' that glorifies the mistreatment of women
27 September 2006
Iran: Gissoo Shakeri - “Voice of women who cannot sing"
Singer Gissoo Shakeri's works are banned in Iran, but her songs can be listened to on the internet. Interview excerpt from Revolution, and lyrics from one of her banned songs
06 April 2006
Mahsa Vahdat
Video interview with female Iranian singer Mahsat Vahdat. Women, religion, and music censorship in modern Iran
17 January 2006
The music industry from the perspective of women
About the music industry from the perspective of women, based on interviews with Myriam, a Senegalese rapper from the group ALIF and the singer Ajah Sy
27 May 2005
Iran: Women & music censorship
Background material on women in the performing arts in post-revolutionary Iran
20 January 2004
Afghanistan: Young singer becomes icon in struggle for freedom of music
18-year-old Lima Sahar has placed herself in the middle of Afghanistan's continous gender and music struggle. She could become the winner of the tv show 'Afghan Star'
13 March 2008
Ghazal Ahmadi
Video interview with an Afghan film actress who explains that she stopped learning how to play the guitar because it became too problematic for her
25 February 2008
Sahar Afarin
Video interview with a 21-year-old Afghan singer who explains how she has been discouraged from music due to pressure from many sides.
25 February 2008
Afghanistan: Female musicians put their lives in danger
A report from a music school in Kabul is a story about the kind of difficulties and dangers female musicians face in present day Afghanistan. They must work in secret
15 January 2008
China: Once banned Taiwanese singer regains popularity
Beijing officials who seven years ago banned the music of Taiwan's pop star A-Mei now use her name to improve political ties between mainland China and Taiwan
17 September 2007
Iran: About 230 people arrested during a ‘satanistic’ music event
As part of an annual summer crackdown on “immoral behavior” about 230 people were arrested during a police raid on an underground rap and rock concert
07 August 2007
Sweden: Explicit lyrics cause heated debate about women’s sexuality
After being banned on two regional radio stations, the lyrics of a song by Frida Muranius are debated in newspapers, radio, web forums and court yards all over Sweden
11 July 2007
Iran: 'Half Moon' - film about women's right to sing
'Half Moon' is a prize-winning feature film which talks of women's right to perform in public, and to participate in the artistic development of a land
25 April 2007
3rd Freemuse World Conference on Music and Censorship
200 professional musicians, scholars, and composers from 22 countries met at the 3rd Freemuse World Conference on 25-26 November 2006 in Istanbul, Turkey
18 December 2006
Syria: 'Silenced voices'
In Syria, music is a mirror which shows the soul of the listener. A few young musicians perceive a magic language of sound which can touch the heart and make new thoughts spark. And this is exacly where their problems start...
07 November 2006
Maryam Mursal
Video interview with Somali singer Maryam Mursal about music prohibition among Islamists
26 October 2006
India: American singer censored on tv
Paris Hilton’s music video ‘Stars Are Blind’ has been banned because of “sexual connotations”.
24 August 2006
USA/UK: Deeyah speaks out about the unspeakable
Freemuse hands the microphone to Deeyah - a pop singer and an activist with a serious message. She has placed herself in the crossfire of today’s most controversial, religious issues
09 August 2006
Afghanistan: Interview with Jamshid Matin X
This is an interview with Jamshid Matin X – a presenter and producer for a daily music show and a Top 10 music show – who fled to America because of death threats
01 June 2006
UK: Tv channel bans music video because of threats
Deeyah’s music video has been taken off air and banned by a British Asian tv channel as they received threats to their staff for airing it
27 February 2006
Afghanistan: Bittersweet success of secret girl band
The Afghan girl group, ‘Burka Band,’ continues to receive media attention and draw new fans, even though they are no longer active.
13 October 2005
Norway/United Kingdom: Muslim pop singer faces threats
During 10 years, threats from angry conservative Muslims silenced the Norwegian and Muslim pop singer Deeyah. Now she breaks her silence.
26 September 2005
Wajihi Rastagar
Interview with Wajiha Rastagar, one of the most famous Afghan female singers, about her first steps towards music, and how she sees the present situation in the country today
30 May 2005
Afghanistan: 24-year-old female presenter of music show killed
On May 18, 2005, ex-TV presenter Shaima Rezayee, 24, was shot in Kabul by unknown men. Her killing is possibly linked to her presenting of the music show ‘Hop’.
19 May 2005
Women and Music Censorship - Past to Present
Examples from all over the world of the censorship of female music during the centuries
25 April 2005
Postscript to report on censorship in Zimbabwe
"Playing with Fire: Fear and Self-Censorship in Zimbabwean Music". Extensive Freemuse report, including case studies on Thomas Mapfumo and Oliver Mtukudzi. Read abstract and full report (PDF)
05 January 2005
Googoosh: Iran's Daughter
Googoosh was Iran's most famous and beloved pop diva, until she was silenced following the 1979 Islamic revolution. The award winning documentary on Googoosh is now out on DVD
14 December 2004
Zimbabwean gospel diva Fungisai Zvakavapano denied UK visa
A London-based Zimbabwe news website quoted a British Embassy official as citing fear that she might not return to Zimbabwe after her tour as a reason for refusing her a visa
02 November 2004
Iranian rapper talks a fine line
Chart-topping Shahkar Binesh-Pajouh targets unemployment, poverty and westernised Iranian girls in his new album, which the culture ministry took four years to approve. The ministry passed it only after he deleted six songs from his original ten
04 September 2004
Venue expels Linda Ronstadt after political remarks
The singer was booed and removed from a Las Vegas casino for praising film-maker Michael Moore and his film Fahrenheit 9/11 during a show. Ronstadt called Moore a "great American patriot" and "someone who is spreading the truth"
20 July 2004
Taiwan star silenced by China row
Taiwanese pop singer Chang Hui-mei, better known as A-mei, had to cancel a concert in China after a protest accusing her of supporting independence for the island
13 June 2004
Shoot the Singer! Book
"Shoot the Singer! Music Censorship Today". The first worldwide presentation of contemporary cases of music censorship, with cases from i.a. Burma, Mexico, Middle East, France, Algeria, Zimbabwe, USA, South Africa, Turkey. Edited by Freemuse director Marie Korpe, published by Zed Books, May 2004.
25 May 2004
Singer 'strips' over censorship
Wearing a "nude suit" on stage to complain about censorship in the US, Alanis Morissette criticised a radio station for forcing her to change strong language in one of her recent songs
06 April 2004
Najwa Karam banned by the Lebanese Censorship Committee
In March 2004, the Lebanese Surete Generale censored a video clip entitled "Why are You Emigrating?" by Najwa Karam, a well known singer.
02 April 2004
Woman singer angers Afghan judges
Afghanistan's supreme court has complained to the government over the appearance of an Afghan woman singing on state television.
16 January 2004
Afghan TV U-turn on women singers
Afghan state television has gone back on a decision to show female singers, saying the country is not yet ready for such broadcasts.
16 January 2004
Afghanistan: Ban on local women singers lifted
More than two years after the fall of the Talibans, state television has broadcast for the first time footage of an Afghan woman singing
14 January 2004
Sarah Jones and FCC
Interview from BBC with the US singer, who has faced several problems in regards to her allegedly controversial lyrics
14 January 2004
Singer Lee Jones attacks Bush
American singer Rickie Lee Jones has attacked the policies of the Bush administration on her latest record - despite the potential risk to her career. “I usually reflect things totally internally. But I think what is happening in America is so disturbing to me, it becomes internal”
07 January 2004